NJ Spotlight News
American Dream blue law defiance vexes Bergen officials
Clip: 1/28/2025 | 4m 35sVideo has Closed Captions
The blue laws ban ‘non-essential’ retail sales on Sundays
For more than a year, the American Dream megamall has openly flouted Bergen County’s blue laws that prohibit “non-essential” retail sales on Sundays, and Mayor Christopher DiPiazza of Paramus is tired of it. DiPiazza says almost every business in Bergen County follows the blue laws, which date to the 1600s.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
NJ Spotlight News is a local public television program presented by THIRTEEN PBS
NJ Spotlight News
American Dream blue law defiance vexes Bergen officials
Clip: 1/28/2025 | 4m 35sVideo has Closed Captions
For more than a year, the American Dream megamall has openly flouted Bergen County’s blue laws that prohibit “non-essential” retail sales on Sundays, and Mayor Christopher DiPiazza of Paramus is tired of it. DiPiazza says almost every business in Bergen County follows the blue laws, which date to the 1600s.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch NJ Spotlight News
NJ Spotlight News is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipIn our spotlight on Business Report tonight, American Dream Mall is facing possible legal consequences after flouting Bergen County's blue laws.
Leaders in Paramus say they're planning to sue the owners of the Mega-Mall after confirming its retail stores have been open to shoppers on Sundays for nearly a year.
Defying the century old law that all other malls and retail shops within the county have strictly followed.
Ted Goldberg has the latest.
Bergen County's blue laws are older than the United States of America, but for more than a year, American Dream Mall has defied those laws by allowing retail shopping on Sundays.
I didn't realize we were in Bergen County, but now I understand why There's a lot of signs here that say open seven days a week.
It's kind of like, hey, we don't care that that's not the right way to go about things if you want change.
You know, we we go through it through to governing bodies, through lobbying.
Paramus Mayor Christopher de Piazza is threatening to sue the Mega-Mall, saying other Bergen County businesses are losing business by following the law.
You're putting the businesses that for decades, for decades that have all been in it together at a disadvantage, an unfair disadvantage.
De Piazza has praised the blue laws for giving locals a break from traffic.
Having that sun where there's that, just that extra peace and quiet, the roads are a little bit more empty.
It gives our emergency services.
There's less calls, less volume because gives them that that day data regroup, kind of everybody that day to regroup.
It's part of our way of life.
American Dream does not operate these retail stores when MetLife Stadium hosts NFL games.
And they've argued that they're exempt from county laws because the land is state owned.
The potential lawsuit has sparked a larger discussion about blue laws in general.
The time is long overdue to repeal the blue laws.
They're archaic.
They're absurd.
John Harlow leads the new Jersey Retail Merchants Association.
And he believes American Dream would win a lawsuit against other municipalities in Bergen County.
More power to American dream.
I think it's the right interpretation of the law.
I think they're doing the right thing.
And quite honestly, I don't think Bergen County has a leg to stand on.
The other malls in Bergen County want no part of this beef over blue laws.
Garden State Plaza told us in a statement that they have created unique ways for our guests to enjoy our property on Sundays while complying with both the county and borough regulations.
Paramus has the support of County executive Jim Tedesco, who told us that American Dream's disregard of the state statute is deeply concerning, and its violation gives American Dream Mall tenants an unfair advantage over all other Bergen County businesses lawfully complying with state law.
Protecting the business community is also protecting our residents, not just their way of life, but also their pocket.
Once, once the businesses in Paramus are disadvantaged, when other businesses are going against the current law, then you know that's not fair.
Some folks, like North Arlington Mayor Daniel Prunty, say a law should be passed allowing each municipality to vote on blue laws.
Technically, blue laws are existing state law, but each county has opted out of them.
Except, of course, for Bergen County, the Landlord for American Dream, the New Jersey Sports and Exposition Authority declined our request for interview, but has argued in court that they are not an enforcement body responsible for policing state statutes.
If the county has a rule saying you have to close, they make the rules, vote for other people.
Shoppers I spoke with were of two minds about this.
I like having peace and quiet.
That's good.
However, if somebody needs something, then you know, you need to have a store.
Everybody's working.
Trying to make ends meet has like family that it's really unrealistic to have stores close on Sundays when that that's one or two days that they may have to shop.
I think there's pros and cons to it.
Right.
But I would say if you know, that's something that you have a problem with, definitely don't move to Bergen County.
If the state doesn't pass a law allowing municipalities to decide, the state could overturn blue laws entirely, which is unlikely.
They could also be thrown out from a ballot referendum.
But previous referendum efforts have gone down in flames.
All of those scenarios are unlikely, so a legal showdown could be inevitable in Bergen County.
I'm Ted Goldberg.
NJ Spotlight News.
Advocates field calls from people who are ‘terrified’
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 1/28/2025 | 5m 50s | Interview: Alexandra Goncalves Pena, American Friends Service Committee (5m 50s)
A hospital groundbreaking in Camden drew powerful guests
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 1/28/2025 | 3m 49s | Five NJ governors and indicted South Jersey powerbroker George Norcross (3m 49s)
NJ drones were authorized by FAA, White House says
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 1/28/2025 | 1m 3s | Many ‘were also hobbyists, recreational and private individuals’ (1m 3s)
Trump ban of trans service members a 'grave disappointment'
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: 1/28/2025 | 7m 28s | Interview: Jennifer Long, transgender Army veteran, speaks to the impact (7m 28s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- News and Public Affairs
Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
- News and Public Affairs
FRONTLINE is investigative journalism that questions, explains and changes our world.
Support for PBS provided by:
NJ Spotlight News is a local public television program presented by THIRTEEN PBS