The Mystery of the Cretaceous Pompeii
Season 7 Episode 13 | 10m 39sVideo has Closed Captions
When you take a deeper look at Pompeii, a different story could be told about the final moments.
Since the 1990s, paleontologists have been pulling 125-million-year-old complete dinosaur skeletons from the rocks of the Lujiatun in Northeastern China, most seemingly posed in perfect rest. This has prompted comparisons to a famous archeological site where behavior is similarly well preserved: the site of Pompeii, a town crystallized by volcanic eruption almost 2000 years ago.
The Mystery of the Cretaceous Pompeii
Season 7 Episode 13 | 10m 39sVideo has Closed Captions
Since the 1990s, paleontologists have been pulling 125-million-year-old complete dinosaur skeletons from the rocks of the Lujiatun in Northeastern China, most seemingly posed in perfect rest. This has prompted comparisons to a famous archeological site where behavior is similarly well preserved: the site of Pompeii, a town crystallized by volcanic eruption almost 2000 years ago.
How to Watch Eons
Eons is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Welcome to Eons!
Join hosts Michelle Barboza-Ramirez, Kallie Moore, and Blake de Pastino as they take you on a journey through the history of life on Earth. From the dawn of life in the Archaean Eon through the Mesozoic Era — the so-called “Age of Dinosaurs” -- right up to the end of the most recent Ice Age.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship125 million years ago in Northwestern China, a dinosaur laid down to sleep…and never woke up.
And it wasn't alone.
Since the 1990s, paleontologists have been pulling complete dinosaur skeletons from the rocks of the Lujiatun in Liaoning Province, most of them seemingly posed in perfect rest.
These fossils include all kinds of dinosaurs – like, a carnivorous troodontid that was found with its neck curled around its body, an early example of how most birds sleep today.
Nearby, early hadrosaurs were found tucked up comfortably with their rigid tails sticking out straight behind them.
All are beautifully preserved whole, covered gently by a blanket of ashy rock that has kept them protected all this time.
But not all the residents were dozing quite so peacefully.
In 2023 a new set of fossils was described that reveals an early ceratopsian with a porcupine-like tail, Psittacosaurus, and a weasel-shaped early mammal, Repenomamus, entombed together.
The animals are entwined.
The fingers of Repenomamus are locked tightly around the dinosaur's jaw and its teeth are sunk deep into the ribs of Psittacosaurus.
This fossilized scene seems to capture a fight between a voracious mammal and its unlucky prey, covered and killed together in the middle of their engagement.
Fossils like this tell us so much about extinct animals that we never would otherwise know – things like hunting technique or even normal body postures.
And Lujiatun has often been compared to a famous archeological site where behavior is also well preserved: the site of Pompeii, a town crystallized by a volcanic eruption almost 2000 years ago.
But while it seems like something similar must have happened to freeze these two places in time, when you look at the details, it turns out that their residents may have experienced very different final moments.
In both Pompeii and Lujiatun, residents were preserved in their daily lives, with no evidence that they saw death coming and tried to avoid it.
It’s odd – almost a geological contradiction.
If an eruption or flood is moving fast enough to catch you off guard, it should also have enough strength to pick you up and toss your body around like a ragdoll – and, presumably, wake you up.
If the eruption is so slow that it wouldn’t disturb your body, you’d probably see it coming, even if you couldn’t outrun it.
So, in these two places, something caused instantaneous death and then also preservation.
This is exceptionally rare.
And yet, some scientists actually think that the two events happened in different ways.
Lujiatun's story started when China was splitting apart.
To the east, a new Pacific plate was forming.
Its birth was not easy for the existing plates, which got pushed and pulled in uncomfortable ways.
The once stable continental rock began to thin and crumple, leading to valleys and lots and lots of volcanoes.
These volcanoes were similar to Mt.
Vesuvius, the volcano that would later kill the residents of Pompeii.
In both cases, some of the magma was full of dissolved water and thick, viscous silica.
And so instead of spewing slow-flowing lava, these volcanoes could explode in violent eruptions of ash.
When these eruptions are big enough and the conditions are right, this ash can flow down a hillside in a superheated mixture of gas and rock, a lethal event known as a pyroclastic flow.
These flows can reach speeds of more than 100 kilometers per hour and can travel many kilometers away from the original volcano.
This is the exact sort of eruption that covered the residents of Pompeii.
But in Lujiatun, the rocks point to something a little different.
They seem to have originally been a pyroclastic flow, but one that was… reshuffled a bit, with the rocks not quite in the right order… As if the ash had been laid down, then picked back up and moved again.
This can happen many ways: if that pyroclastic flow hits a river, for example, or erupts through a glacier, or if a big rainstorm floods down upon loose ash.
In any case, the result is the same: a volcanic mudslide known as a lahar.
Lahars are also devastating – they can be hot or cold, and in steep areas can reach over 200 kilometers per hour.
But there is one big difference between lahars and pyroclastic flows, and that is how they change as they slow down.
By the time the pyroclastic flow from Mt.
Vesuvius traveled the roughly 8 kilometers to the town of Pompeii, it had lost some of its original density and thickness, becoming almost fluffy.
It was still fast enough to cover a person, but light enough to not move their body.
But lahars are much thicker than pyroclastic ash clouds—so thick that they’re often described as “concrete.” They can slow down and become more liquid and gentle, but the problem still remains: a lahar that was fast enough to catch and kill a dinosaur without even waking it up would also have been powerful enough to fling the dinosaur downstream.
So even if Lujiatun experienced one, that would only be a piece of the puzzle.
And both the residents of Pompeii and the dinosaurs of Lujiatun were preserved quickly, as if the rocks took a snapshot of their lives… and the explanation for how that happened might be hidden in their body posture.
The story is, perhaps, a bit simpler in Pompeii - or maybe we just know it better.
After all, people were there to watch it happen and write about it.
The pyroclastic flow hit the town in the morning, when most residents were awake.
Approximately 70% of the townspeople were preserved in relatively life-like postures - walking, sitting, crawling, and in some cases, sleeping.
But there are small details in their postures that are different from daily life.
For example, 64% of the bodies show flexed arms and fingers.
And although these were initially interpreted as people trying to defend themselves from the ash, we now know it happened due to a phenomenon called pugilistic attitude.
This is a positional change that occurs when muscles and tendons are rapidly dehydrated.
The pyroclastic flow that hit Pompeii was so hot that it caused almost instantaneous death, frying people in place.
The ash then settled around their bodies, which were covered in more rocks and ash as the eruption continued, eventually preserving the town in around 7 meters of sediment.
But none of the dinosaurs in Lujiatan show pugilistic postures or any apparent reaction to their entombment.
This has led some scientists to theorize that perhaps these dinosaurs were preserved in their burrows, which may have collapsed and killed them immediately.
But that doesn't seem to explain all of the cases.
Like, one especially sad fossil shows a group of 24 juvenile Psittacosaurus.
All of the babies' bodies are rotated slightly, as if they'd been pushed around by a weak current - something difficult to do inside of a burrow.
So, this fossil points to a lahar.
And Repenomamus also shows small signs it was moved by a current.
Its back leg is trapped within the bent knee of the Psittacosaurus it was trying to eat, suggesting the two bodies were shifted slightly before their final preservation.
Yet none of the sleeping dinosaurs show any signs of waking.
And Repenomamus seems to have been thoroughly enjoying its last meal.
So…how did they all miss the lahar?
Well, it's possible that they were already dead.
See, volcanoes can also have eruptions of pure gas, including CO2, which is odorless and invisible.
CO2 is normally a safe component of our planet's atmosphere, but at high enough concentrations, it's deadly to breathe.
It can cause unconsciousness almost instantaneously, then within a minute: respiratory arrest and death.
And this is what some scientists think happened to many of the dinosaurs at Lujiatun, especially those that were preserved sleeping.
They were killed by invisible gas almost instantly - as quickly as the residents of Pompeii, if not as dramatically.
Then, before their bodies could collapse or rot, they were preserved in place by a slow-moving lahar.
Now, excavations at Lujiatun continue – with new discoveries each year.
But one problem with Lujiatun dinosaurs is that they are often found by farmers and locals and excavated before paleontologists arrive.
So it can be difficult to tell exactly what layer they came from.
Fortunately, these dinosaurs still have some of their original sediment stuck to their bones.
And analyses of this sediment determined that not all of the sleeping dinosaurs have even come from the same location or the same eruption.
That means that this deadly combination of gas and ash may have happened more than once.
The conditions that preserve behavior in the fossil record are unusual, but Lujiatun seems to have been a perfect storm of volcanic influences.
And surprisingly, it was probably a different perfect storm than Pompeii saw.
Lujiatun’s sleeping dinosaurs have taught us a lot – like that Psittacosaurus took care of its young and was hunted by much smaller mammals, and even that the tails of some early hadrosaurs were too rigid to bend!
They may have been caused by different geological events and took place millions of years apart, but sites like Pompeii and Lujiatun give us a unique window into daily life that we would otherwise never see – even if that life was taking a nap.